The Power of One Striking Detail: The Man in the Hathaway Shirt

An eyepatch and a dress shirt made history. In 1951, Hathaway ran this ad featuring a dapper man with an unexpected twist: a black eye patch. Nothing else needed explaining. The image was so unusual it stopped readers mid-page—and then they read the copy.

Why It Works

• Visual Hook: The eyepatch created instant intrigue.

• Clear Product Tie: The shirt stayed the hero, not the gimmick.

• Contrasting Elements: Refined clothing meets rugged mystery.

• Emotional Pull: It made the viewer imagine a backstory.

• Repetition Power: Consistent branding around “The Man in the Hathaway Shirt.”

Real-World Examples

• Dos Equis’ “Most Interesting Man in the World” used mystery to sell beer.

• Old Spice’s “The Man Your Man Could Smell Like” leaned on contrast and surprise.

• Apple’s “Think Different” cast famous rebels to spark intrigue and aspiration.

Creative Variations

Hand-drawn pen style

Classic 1950s print ad

Futuristic style

Funny style